Annie finds Tyus's informations about infertility and she thinks of a great way to use it against Caitlin. Caitlin, who was interrupted by Gregory while stealing his money, lies to him about the reason why she wants him money. Caitlin goes to Rachel to finish her deal, but she's stopped by Annie, who tells her that she knows about her infertility. However, Caitlin lies to her, and tells her it's for her friend. The people on the Terror Island still hallucinate, especially Meg, who thinks that Ben is about to kill her, just like he did it to Maria. Tim figures out that someone put something in the soup. Gabi is shaken by her hallucinations of her abuser from childhood, her father Lorenzo. Mark says to Gabi that he likes her, in his way. Meanwhile, Jade is trying to rescue herself, and she pulls off the mask off her attacker and recognizes him, which leaves another mystery -- who of the known people is the killer.
