Susan

Jane Lynch

Sophie Lennon

John Scurti

Nicky

Erik Palladino

Frank

Chris Eigeman

Gabe

Nina Arianda

Hedy

Peter Friedman

George

Matilda Szydagis

Zelda

Alexander Gemignani

Janusz

Colin Keane

Ethan

Ireland Carvajal

Esther

Sedona Carvajal

Esther

Annie Golden

Marge

Austin Basis

Alvin

Josh Grisetti

Ralph

Lucas Kavner

Cecil

Eddie Kaye Thomas

Adam

Michael Cyril Creighton

Mel

Malika Samuel

Dorie

Chloë Kerwin

Trudy

David Carl

Teddy

John Noble Barrack

Stage Manager

Emily Bergl

Tessie

David Chase

Band Leader

Kerry Butler

Tuppance

Valisia LeKae

Lucy

Robert Ray Manning Jr.

Toby

Brittany Nicole Parks

Tulip

Ethan Slater

Steven

Alex Wyse

Jerome

Luke Thomas

Angelic Little Boy

Joel Blum

Bus Driver

Jeffrey Bean

Carl

Emily Morden

Tina

Nick Jacinto

Hart Buckley

Jane Corcoran

Garbage Man